DPReview’s review of the Fujifilm GFX 100 medium format camera shows the consequences of having dead pixels whose space is used for phase detection autofocus (PDAF) modules:
If you know what you’re looking for, you can even see them on the 3EV pushed sample. To me, this would be an argument for avoiding use of this camera – I think anybody would reasonably expect not to come across problems like this after doing a shoot with a 10k USD camera.
TechInsights have shown that there is an increasing trend in PDAF pixel adoption, at least in iPhones:
The banding is also present on GFX 50R images, just not as strongly:
Other data mentioned in passing in the review show Nikon’s Z6 and especially Z7 to also suffer from the problem:
And that’s not the first time that Nikon has run into banding problems.
There’s currently a rumour going around that Sony will soon stop manufacturing sensors without this problem, potentially leaving Canon cameras as the only option for photographers that don’t want to deal with the above.
If you dislike this, you should consider making your voice heard, and making this a criterion in the next camera you buy.
[…] Regardless, the bottom line on this camera is that in 2019, nobody should be recommending a camera without IBIS, such as the X-A7, to any general photographer. Based on the large number of phase-detect autofocus pixels on the sensor, I would also expect this camera to exhibit banding. […]
[…] can prove itself for newcomers to the Pentax platform, and that Pentax after its excursion to an Emmental sensor with the KP (whose effect on image quality admittedly is difficult to estimate) can return to a […]
[…] else is there to say about the Z50? It’s got a 21 megapixel BSI CMOS Emmental sensor, single SD card slot, and pop-up flash. Its 3.2″ touchscreen rear display tilts 180° […]
[…] both cameras seem to have “fake pixel” phase detection autofocus systems, the XF10 has 91 focus points, while the GR III’s details […]
[…] is by contrast detection only, which avoids the banding problems associated with “Emmental” sensors. Chris from DPReview TV (formerly of CameraStore TV) says the results are less satisfactory than […]
[…] live view, the D780 uses the same autofocus system as the Z6, at the cost of an Emmental cheese sensor, using 2733 PDAF “holes” in the sensor that cover 90% of the frame. In live view, […]
[…] Why I keep writing ’bout holes in the sensor […]
[…] a 32 megapixel sensor. Until that point, the only APS-C sensor beyond 24 megapixels was one that wasn’t really 26 […]
[…] is new and branded BIONZ XR. Improvements to autofocus sound incremental – there are over 700 autofocus holes distributed over 92% the frame, and person, eye and animal AF modes are […]